Black Cadillac in Rain

How To Spot a Lemon

Buying a used car can be a smart financial decision, but it also comes with risks — especially if you unknowingly drive off the lot with a lemon. A lemon car is a vehicle with significant defects that impact its safety, value, or functionality. The good news is that you don't have to leave it up to chance. There are clear warning signs that can help you steer clear of a bad deal. At Easterns Automotive Group, we believe in transparency and want you to feel confident in your car-buying decision.

Before you commit to a used car, here's a quick guide to why a lemon title is given to a car and how to tell if a car is a lemon.

What Is a Lemon?

A Black Cadillac Car Parked on the Street by Collin Nederhood is licensed with Pexels License

A lemon is a vehicle with a serious defect that just won't go away, even after multiple repair attempts. If the issue affects the car's value, performance, or safety and the manufacturer or dealer can't fix it in a reasonable amount of time, the law may require the manufacturer to replace the car or give the owner a refund. This applies to some leased cars, too, depending on the state.

After repurchase, a lemon car can be repaired and resold. Some states require the title to be marked as a "lemon law buyback," but that's not always the case, especially if the car has changed hands multiple times. That's why it's important to do your homework when shopping for a used car. Knowing what to look for can help you avoid a frustrating and expensive mistake.


The Basics of Lemon Laws

Lemon laws are designed to protect consumers who unknowingly purchase a vehicle with serious defects. While lemon laws vary by state, the Washington D.C., Lemon Law offers protections for drivers who experience persistent vehicle issues early in ownership.

Lemon Law Coverage in Washington, D.C.

In Washington, D.C., a vehicle qualifies as a lemon if it develops a defect within the first 24 months or 18,000 miles (whichever comes first), and the issue remains unresolved after a reasonable number of repair attempts — typically four. However, a car may also be eligible if:

  • It has been in the shop for 30 days or more within the first year, whether consecutive or not.
  • A serious, life-threatening defect occurs at least twice.

The Washington, D.C., lemon law makes things easier by requiring manufacturers to cover legal fees and provide compensation if you win the case. This law applies to both purchased and leased vehicles, but most used cars aren't covered unless they still have a valid manufacturer's warranty, so be careful. If a dealership misrepresents a car's condition, you may still have legal options under the Unfair Trade Practices Act or the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, which protect against warranty breaches. Understanding these laws can help you get a fair resolution for a defective vehicle.

How To Avoid Buying a Lemon Car

Data shows that Fiat, Cadillac, General Motors, Volvo, Land Rover, and Ford are among the manufacturers with the highest number of reported lemon vehicles. Whenever you're buying a used car, be mindful of the manufacturer while making a purchase. Here are some of the most common ways to avoid getting tricked into buying a lemon car.

Look for Red Flags in Online Ads

Scammers often post fake car listings, advertising vehicles at unrealistically low prices to trick you into sending deposits or providing personal information. For instance, you might be convinced to wire money for a deposit to hold the car, only to discover later that it's a lemon car. To safeguard yourself, always avoid transactions that require upfront payments without verifying the car's availability. Insist on meeting the seller in person and inspecting the car firsthand before committing to any payment.

Evaluating Exterior and Interior Condition

When checking the car's exterior, look for mismatched paint or parts that don't line up correctly. These could be signs that the car met with an accident and was poorly repaired, suggesting hidden problems.

Take a close look at the tires. If the tread is uneven, it could mean the car wasn't properly maintained — for example, by skipping tire rotations or alignments. If you notice this, it could lead to bigger issues. You should also pay attention to the interior. Excessive wear, such as ripped seats or frayed seat belts, suggests the car wasn't taken care of and might have more serious problems under the surface.

Importance of a Thorough Test-Drive

A test-drive helps you feel how the car runs. You can check the engine, listen for strange noises, and see how it handles. Pay attention to the brakes, steering, and suspension. A good test-drive can uncover hidden issues, such as transmission problems or odd vibrations. Always drive the car in different conditions to ensure it's in good shape before you decide to buy it.

Investigating Vehicle History

Always ask for a full vehicle history report from a trusted provider, such as those approved by the National Motor Vehicle Title Information System. While many dealers offer a free CARFAX, a paid report gives you more detailed information, including title brands, accident history, owner history, repair records, and safety recalls. If a car was bought back by the manufacturer or has repeated repairs for the same issue, it might be a lemon law buyback.

Contact Easterns Automotive Group Today for Used Vehicles

At Easterns Automotive Group, we understand the importance of finding a reliable used vehicle in the Washington, D.C., area. Our team is dedicated to helping you avoid any potential lemon cars by offering clear details about each vehicle's history and condition. We provide full transparency and work with trusted sources to ensure you get the best deal. With our wide selection of quality used cars, we'll help you find a vehicle that meets your needs and budget. Contact us today to get started and drive away with confidence.